Skip to main content

New recruiting rankings update provides Matt Campbell with more proof of concept for his Penn State plan

With David Tarawallie reaching five-star status and Elijah Guertin climbing into the top 100, Penn State's early identification strategy is paying big dividends.
ByJosh Yourish
Elijah Guertin, Hendricken Football
Elijah Guertin, Hendricken Football | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

Penn State hasn’t won many big-time battles on the recruiting trail. Matt Campbell and his general manager, Derek Hoodjer, better known for uncovering hidden gems at Iowa State, haven’t quite proven they can go head-to-head with big-money powerhouses for top talent and come out on top. 

Yet, after 247Sports' rankings update on Wednesday, the Nittany Lions have five top 200 recruits in the country and a five-star offensive tackle, David Tarawallie. Without adding a single player, Penn State’s 2027 class jumped to No. 17 in the country, up four spots from No. 21. 

Tarawallie, who committed to Campbell’s program when he was just a three-star, as did defensive end Elijah Guertin, who is now the No. 71 overall player in the country and the No. 8 EDGE following the update. 

You’d have to imagine that, eventually, this staff will need to win a few more high-profile contests to get over the hump as a real Big Ten and national championship contender, but Campbell was brought to Penn State with exactly this in mind, and this latest round of rankings is meaningful proof of concept. 

Matt Campbell has new peers, and his staff is still out identifying them 

Campbell became the most successful coach in Iowa State football history largely by doing exactly this: uncovering hidden gems on the recruiting trail and developing them into stars. The theory at Penn State is that, with a significant upgrade in resources, that operation could level up to find and hold onto players like Tarawallie, whom Iowa State would never have been able to afford once he reached five-star status. 

It still remains to be seen whether Penn State will get this class across the finish line with the early signing period looming at the start of December. It has already lost a few commitments, but key pieces like Tarawallie, Guertin, in-state offensive tackle Ryan Robbins, and top-150 defensive back Kei’Shjuan Telfair appear solid. 

Hidden gems who commit to Iowa State can largely stay hidden. When Penn State starts to offer, they usually get found out. That’s probably a big reason players in this class are seeing a major rankings bump by both Rivals, which did its penultimate update for this class on Monday, and 247. 

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

Still, even with more cache, and when the goal is to go from uncovering zero-stars who should be three-stars to three-stars who should be top-100 players, there are significantly bigger fish swimming in that pool with you. At least thus far, it seems this staff is still savvy enough to outmaneuver them. Winning a head-to-head battle with Ohio State for late-rising three-star running back Jordan Hall is a good example of that. It just can’t be the only thing this staff does well in recruiting. 

Early ID still can’t be this staff’s only move

Before the portal was widely adopted across the country, Florida State went all-in and uncovered players like Braden Fiske and Jared Verse to build its 2023 ACC Championship roster. Then, Mike Norvell and his staff convinced themselves that they could do that every year, and that hubris blew up their program. 

This situation isn’t necessarily a one-to-one comparison, because that portal was a new avenue of player acquisition that was more widely adopted after the 2023 season, so Florida State had significantly more competition the next time around. 

The competition will largely stay the same for this Penn State staff as it attempts to capitalize on underrecruited players by being the first to recognize their potential and land a commitment before everyone else catches up. They’re clearly one of the best in the country at talent identification, but only by a matter of degree, not an order of magnitude. It’s not a bankable enough advantage to be the exclusive avenue for talent acquisition. 

If one year you happen to miss a few evaluations and you don’t increase your spending capacity to the point where you can win more head-to-head battles with Ohio State, Michigan, and Notre Dame, which should be your primary competition, you risk assembling a class that’s closer to the 30th best in the country and doesn’t work its way up closer to the top 15, where you need to be if you’re not going to be one of the biggest spenders in the portal. 

There’s also going to be times when you’re in early on a player like Jamir Dean, who was a three-star wide receiver from Tennessee when he committed to Penn State, and Georgia swoops in to flip him as he ascends into the top 100, where he now sits at No. 89. 

This ratings update is absolutely a win for Penn State and proof that this plan of giving a developmentally minded staff that won on the margins at a financially strapped program more resources can help you close the gap to Ohio State. They just can’t trick themselves into believing that there still aren't potential pitfalls to overindulging in this approach.

Add us as a preferred source on Google