Rivals made the penultimate update to its Rivals300 for the 2027 class on Monday, and Penn State had a few top commits who got a boost. Defensive back Kei’Shjuan Telfair jumped to No. 63, defensive tackle Stanley Montgomery moved to No. 106, and linebacker Case Alexander climbed to No. 179 in the class.
The most important moves, however, came at offensive tackle, where four-star commit David Tarawallie nearly cracked five-star status, now checking in at No. 29, and in-state offensive tackle commit Ryan Robbins from Upper St. Clair High School in Western Pennsylvania cracked the Rivals 300 for the first time at No. 227.
The most cynical view is that committing to Penn State increased their exposure and led to the continued ratings increase, a watered-down version of the “Bama bump.” The most charitable view is that head coach Matt Campbell, general manager Derek Hoodjer, and their staff are elite talent evaluators who were in early on hidden gems, and now the rest of the industry is catching up to just how good the No. 21 class in the country might actually be.
Reality is probably somewhere in the middle, but regardless, the fact that two of Penn State’s biggest risers and most important commits in 2027 were along the offensive line is proof that, at least on the recruiting trail, they’re building this program the right way.
David Tarawallie and Ryan Robbins both moved up in the Rivals 300
Campbell often juxtaposes the “right way” to build a team with the transfer-heavy modern approach of the NIL era. That’s not the definition I’m using here. His “right way,” if he’s too dogmatic about it, will leave him falling behind the rest of the Big Ten. No, this “right way” is simply about positional value in that modern era. Elite offensive tackles have one of the highest hit rates of any position out of high school, and in the transfer portal, the demand for quality offensive linemen always outstrips demand and forces overpays relative to true quality.
That’s how you have to think about roster construction now; it’s about maximizing value for the resources you have to allocate, and high school offensive linemen are almost always a great way to spend them. You have to hit on the players, of course, but if you do, and it looks like Penn State may have, you can have a foundation in place for your football team that most programs are scrambling to find in an inflated portal market.
Just look at how this season played out for Penn State. The offensive line was terrible early in the season as it tried to find an identity in the run game and dealt with a nagging injury to center Brock Riker. Now, Riker is healthy, and even with 2025 five-star Malachi Goodman at less than 100%, the group has grown together, settled into a power run game, and looks to be dominant.
It’s hard to bank on all five starters staying relatively healthy all year to have that type of trajectory, so you need to continue to restock the shelves.
It's just good business to build high school classes through the trenches
Anthony Donkoh is walking on Senior Day in Week 12 against Rutgers, so while he has one year of eligibility remaining, he may be off to the NFL. Otherwise, the other four starters are likely going to be back. That doesn’t mean the position is any less important to reload. Attrition can hit an offensive line harder than almost any other unit on the field because one weak link has a more significant effect than anywhere else.
Tarawallie could finish as a five-star. He was a largely unheralded player when Penn State landed him. That’s a win for identification, and if he plays early in his career, it’s a huge recruiting victory. Robbins has been a three-star through much of the process, but a strong senior season has him on the rise as well.
Both players can help to backfill depth, as there are bound to be a few transfer portal departures, as players like Owen Aliciene, who lost the swing tackle battle to Garrett Sexton, seek playing time elsewhere. Aliciene hasn't had to play this year, but with Sexton likely starting at right tackle to replace Donkoh in 2026, he'd be one injury away. So his departure would be significant, unless you can bring in young players who are ready to see the field early to replace him.
Look at Georgia this year - The No. 1 team in the country is starting a true freshman, Zykie Helton, at right guard next to three second-year players along the offensive line. And that offensive line might be the biggest strength of the entire team. There just aren't many 300+ pounders who can really move. If you get the ones who can, they can play early and play well.
In any era, building through the trenches is the way to go for a football program. In this transactional era, where it’s remarkably difficult to build an offensive line through the portal, and elite high school O-line recruits tend to provide a return on investment more reliably than most positions, it’s almost non-negotiable.

