Skip to main content

Matt Campbell deserves credit for Penn State’s turnaround, but his 'shortcut' comments ignore reality

Matt Campbell didn't hit the ground running in Year 1 at Penn State, and that's okay. But the new coaches who do, aren't doing it the wrong way.
ByJosh Yourish
Penn State Nittany Lions head coach Matt Campbell
Penn State Nittany Lions head coach Matt Campbell | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Penn State has gotten better this season. Not every team can say that truthfully 11 weeks in. That’s a credit to first-year head coach Matt Campbell and his staff, who arrived from Iowa State with a developmental ethos and a long-term vision for how they want to build in Happy Valley. 

Campbell reiterated that after his Nittany Lions pounded Minnesota 42-14 at Beaver Stadium on Saturday, extending their win streak to three after starting Big Ten play 0-4, and reaching bowl eligibility with a 6-4 overall record. 

“I don't think I've wavered from my belief in what this football team could become and who they were. There's been a lot that this group, coaching staff included, has had to work through to navigate this whole journey," Campbell said postgame.

"I said it from the beginning that we weren't going to shortcut this process. We weren't going to try to win at all costs. We're going to try to build the right foundation, and we were going to do it the right way. I think this group's got a chance to put a powerful statement together."

And that’s where he lost me. 

Did Curt Cignetti or Bob Chesney take "shortcuts" to their success? 

In an unprecedented era of college football, when a first-time Power Conference head coach can take over Indiana, the losingest program in college football history at the time, and in two years, win the national championship at 16-0, it's telling.  

Aggressive head coaches will turn over their roster in a new place, bring an influx of talented transfers, and win right away. After Curt Cignetti left James Madison to turn Indiana into a juggernaut, Bob Chesney went to UCLA and did the exact same thing. 

They didn’t take “shortcuts.” They, too, are developmentally-minded head coaches, not the blustery Lane Kiffin “Portal King” types intent on wringing the donor base for every dollar it can to import mercenaries. You can’t watch Indiana or UCLA play football and not believe both programs have an elite culture in place. 

And does anything about those rebuilds not look sustainable? The Hoosiers are in Year 3 and Cignetti is saying a loss to Ohio State was a “missed layup.” That program is a juggernaut, and sure the investment is there, but by The Athletic’s reporting, Cignetti’s roster is only the fourth-most expensive roster in the Big Ten, nestled in with USC and Michigan, topping out at about $40 million. 

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

UCLA is below Penn State, somewhere between $26-30 million. 

Those coaches didn’t sacrifice any moral high ground to hit the ground running at their new job. They’re not “winning at all costs,” which, when Campbell says it, I take to mean buying a brand new roster in the portal that doesn’t care about the program, and is only motivated by the paycheck. 

To be clear, that is a real risk. It’s the reason most pundits are concerned that LSU will pack it in after suffering a fourth loss, seeing its CFP hopes officially fade away. However, there’s a ton of room between what Kiffin does and what Cignetti and Chesney have. 

And furthermore, for every Cignetti and Chesney, there are three Campbells, James Franklins, and even a couple of Jon Sumralls or Will Steins who had fantastic moments, but couldn’t string it together for a full season. 

Matt Campbell has a built-in excuse for his struggles, so why make more?

It’s fine that Campbell hit a few bumps in the road in his first season. Yes, Penn State had a remarkably easy schedule in the Big Ten and, because of it, an abnormally clear path to the 12-team CFP, but that was probably never a fair expectation. With that, 8-4, which appears likely, is a fine finish, and the steady improvement is encouraging, even if it’s coming against that soft schedule. 

Campbell faced unique challenges because of how athletic director Pat Kraft botched the head coaching search and hired him after signing day. He’ll never call out his AD for that, but it’s a justifiable explanation for his season, and a defense the fanbase has been making on his behalf. 

That’s all to say that he doesn’t need to create some strawman argument about the “win at all costs” boogeyman to justify a few losses. Two things can be true: You can win immediately and sustainably in a new job in this era of college football. And it’s okay that Campbell didn’t. 

I'm not unconvinced that Campbell's model of player development with a sprinkle of Penn State's improved resources and upgraded recruiting can't yield a legitimate national contender. The fact that he has this roster, which will hopefully be the least talented of his entire tenure, playing so much better by the end of the season than it did in the beginning is the biggest data point in his favor.

He just can't convince himself that the modern mechanisms that are leading to historic turnarounds are somehow immoral. He has to shake this antiquated view of what’s “right” and “wrong” in modern college football, or else he’ll lose a few too many games again in Year 2. What’s his defense going to be then?

Add us as a preferred source on Google