It’s not a foregone conclusion that Penn State finishes at 8-4 with Rutgers and Maryland on deck to finish the season, but after a 42-14 drubbing of Minnesota in Week 11, it certainly feels that way.
In the absence of intrigue for a visit from Greg Schiano’s Scarlet Knights, Tuesday’s press conference featured much more intrigue about the future, questions about roster building and the implications of Senior Day when a few of the players walking still have a season of eligibility left.
One of the fourth-year seniors who isn’t walking is starting linebacker Kooper Ebel, who met with the media on Tuesday after his head coach and quarterback announced that he intends to return for another season in Happy Valley. A veteran starter coming back is typically great news. It is with tight end Benjamin Brahmer who made a similar announcement on Tuesday night, but in Ebel's case, it’s a bit more complicated than that.
Ebel is a good player, but for most serious Power Conference contenders, he’s the type of player you’d look to upgrade over. That might make his situation the perfect litmus test for how Matt Campbell is going to run his new program and whether he’s ruthless enough to build the Big Ten contender that’s expected in Happy Valley.
Kooper Ebel isn’t good enough to be a locked-in starter for 2027
To say Ebel is a bad player is probably an overstatement. However, to say he's a meaningful value-add at the Big Ten level is certainly one. He’s No. 2 on the team with 60 total tackles, plus he has 3.5 for loss and 13 run stops. He’s played 408 snaps and is the green-dot communicator for a unit that has really rounded into shape down the stretch.
However, he also leads the team with 11 missed tackles, and many of them have been glaring on film. At times, even when he makes the play, he’s carried for a few yards. Typically that’s the case for an undersized backer with great sideline-to-sideline speed, but that’s not the case with the 6-foot-4, 233-pound senior.
Ebel’s issues have been less glaring lately, but the offenses Penn State has faced have been worse. Off-ball linebacker is also a position that has a longer developmental curve because of how much is asked of those players. Mental preparedness and anticipation at the position can offset physical limitations, but only to a point.
Maybe, as Ebel gets more comfortable transitioning from the 3-3-5 system Iowa State played to the 4-2-5 he now leads under D’Anton Lynn, he’ll play faster and tackle better. But playing better and playing well are two different things. He also simply may not meet the athletic thresholds necessary to be an impactful off-ball defender in a 4-2-5 at the Big Ten level. No level of familiarity with the defense will change that.
Would recruiting over Kooper Ebel risk long-term damage?
Under Campbell and general manager Derek Hoodjer, Penn State is never going to be a highly transactional roster. Penn State doesn’t spend like Oregon and Ohio State at the very top of the conference, so in their minds, loyalty with an eye to long-term development is one of their biggest recruiting advantages. Largely, that worked to offset financial limitations at Iowa State. It could do the same at Penn State.
So, with Ebel announcing he wants to come back, do you go into the Transfer Portal to recruit over him to upgrade your upside at the position? A lot of programs in the ruthlessly transactional portal era would, and they’d probably be right to. But if you’re Campbell and you do that, does that undercut your message to other recruits? Maybe. But if you don’t, you risk taking too long to meaningfully upgrade the talent level of your roster from your overperforming but ultimately limited Iowa State teams.
The fifth year of eligibility granted to a number of Campbell’s Iowa State imports will force this same issue at other spots on the roster as well. This year’s team was primarily thrown together with building a culture in mind, especially considering how late in the process this staff arrived.
This offseason needs to be about aggressively upgrading, and if they’re not going to show a few players the door and churn the roster as most programs do nowadays, they may fall pretty short of that. Their developmental chops, which are well documented, can close that gap a bit, but only so far.
Another fourth-year senior, left guard Trevor Buhr, is another example. A good player, but one worth attempting to find an upgrade for. How Campbell and Hoodjer handle those two positions this offseason will be an important barometer for how they’ll generally comport themselves in the portal.
A more extreme example is Marcus Neal Jr., who began the year as a starting safety but has since moved to linebacker; outside the 3-3-5 system, he is largely a man without a position. Most head coaches would admit their mistake and wish him well in the portal. It’s a safe bet Penn State won’t. That could be the right call, but it carries significant risk.
Internal options could help thread needle, at least at linebacker
If Penn State doesn’t recruit over Ebel and Buhr, and refuses to show Neal the door, which would be questionable but defensible decisions, the program’s meritocratic nature could help Campbell thread the needle.
This staff isn’t quick to abandon a struggling player. They believe in their guys. But they will make changes if they’re needed. They benched Neal, who was a star at Iowa State, and they allowed Cam Wallace to bubble up the depth chart at running back, essentially putting James Peoples, an Ohio State transfer, on ice.
Even when it may not be in their best long-term interest, as is the case with Rocco Becht keeping the starting quarterback job over Alex Manske, whom they desperately need an answer on for next year, they play the best player. Next year, if everyone is healthy at linebacker, that player may not be Ebel.
With options like Alex Tatsch, who is out with an injury, and Cam Smith, who saw his first significant workload in Week 11 playing SAM linebacker next to Ebel and Tony Rojas, Penn State may not need a portal addition to upgrade at MIKE. Rojas, a fourth-year senior who is walking on Saturday, is likely off to the NFL this offseason. That will open snaps at WILL and, presumably, kick off a competition between Tatsch and Smith.
However, if those former James Franklin recruits are simply the two best linebackers on the team, that competition may extend to MIKE. Frankly, with the way Ebel has played this year, it should. Just because he’s coming back doesn’t mean he should be handed the green dot again. Hopefully, whether it’s through a portal acquisition or internal competition, he’s not, because that means Penn State is better at an important position and Campbell isn’t loyal to a fault.

