Skip to main content

5 thoughts from Matt Campbell and Penn State’s Week 12 press conference before Senior Day

The Nittany Lions are preparing for their final home game of 2026 as they host Rutgers at Beaver Stadium on Saturday.
ByJosh Yourish
Penn State Nittany Lions head coach Matt Campbell
Penn State Nittany Lions head coach Matt Campbell | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Head coach Matt Campbell, offensive coordinator Taylor Mouser, quarterback Rocco Becht, and linebacker Kooper Ebel all took to the podium after practice on Tuesday as Penn State prepares to host Rutgers at Beaver Stadium this weekend. 

As Senior Day approaches in the final home game of the year, it was a reflective mood for the leaders of a program that has bounced back with a three-game win streak after starting the Big Ten slate 4-0. With an eye toward the future and some thoughts about this year, there was a lot to unpack from the team’s most extensive media availability of the week. 

5. Rocco Becht’s hidden value is statistically provable

Taylor Mouser was asked a very astute question about where Rocco Becht’s “veteran-ness,” as Campbell has described it throughout the year, shows up for them in ways that fans may not see.

Throughout Becht’s struggles early in the year, that was also the default defense from Campbell and Mouser, but without any explanation of how that was actually showing up, especially before this recent three-game stretch when he was turning the ball over and making mistakes you would hope not to see from the most experienced quarterback in college football.

Mouser also had an excellent response: “We haven’t taken a lot of negative rushing plays on the ground because Rocco gets us into the best play a majority of the time.” He continued to explain how much autonomy Becht has at the line to control the run game. 

If you look at the numbers, it’s true. Penn State is a bit of a weird outlier when you look at success rate and stuff rate for a run game. Even after this late-season resurgence, it ranks No. 104 in success rate, but is No. 11 in stuff rate at just 12%. That’s easily one of the biggest discrepancies in the country. 

Rush success rate vs. Rush stuff rate
Rush success rate vs. Rush stuff rate | GameOnPaper

It was probably the most interesting exchange of the press conference because it felt like a moment where this staff was (respectfully) being called to show their hand, and honestly, to my surprise, they weren’t bluffing. 

4. The late start really did hamper Matt Campbell’s Year 1 roster build

For all the improvement his team has made over the course of the season, Matt Campbell’s roster simply isn’t up to the talent level that is expected in Happy Valley.

His staunchest defenders have largely blamed athletic director Pat Kraft for that because Kraft’s unsuccessful forays with other head coaches during the hiring process led him to Campbell after the early signing period had already passed. 

Campbell hasn’t thrown his new AD under the bus for that or passed any blame, but he hinted at it on Tuesday:

“We were in absolute scramble mode,” Campbell said of last December when he arrived. “You’re trying to meet new people, figure out what fits, and then I really think we went with the mentality a year ago, you know, trying to find the right humans before we were even talking about, what’s a right tackle look like in this system? What’s a defensive end look like in this system? I think as late of a jump as we had in the process, it was way more about getting the right locker room and the right people.” 

I’m not entirely sure that’s the right approach in an era when coaches like Curt Cignetti and Bob Chesney are turning programs around on a dime in Year 1. But for his circumstances, it’s a justifiable plan.

Right now it’s a reason for optimism that in the future, he and his staff will be more aggressive about trying to upgrade the talent level than they were when they brought 24 transfers from Iowa State this offseason. 

3. Who is walking on Senior Day doesn’t mean a lot, but it doesn’t mean nothing

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

On Monday, Penn State released the list of 25 players who will be honored for Senior Day on Saturday as the Nittany Lions host Rutgers at Beaver Stadium. That list includes Anthony Donkoh, Andrew Rapplyea, Tony Rojas, Carson Hansen, Zion Tracy, and a few others who have eligibility remaining due to the NCAA’s new age-based eligibility rules passed this summer. 

Campbell explained that “some guys still have eligibility that are still working through the process and just didn’t feel like they were ready to walk on Senior Day, other guys have eligibility that are walking on Senior Day, and probably will wait till the end of the season to make a final decision if they come back. So, really it’s just a personal preference, and I’ll be honest with you, I don’t even really get into it. We get into all those meetings after the season.” 

So, just because that group of players is walking on Saturday doesn’t mean that this will be their last year at Penn State, or in college football. However, it does mean that it might be, because other seniors with eligibility remaining, like linebacker Kooper Ebel, aren’t walking. 

That’s because, as he confirmed later during the availability, Ebel will likely be back for 2027. “I do plan on coming back to Penn State next year. I’m obviously trying to finish this season on a high note. We’ve got a ton of momentum going, but yeah, that’s the plan for now.” 

So again, just because Donkoh is walking doesn’t mean he won’t be the team’s starting right tackle next year. But it does mean he’s weighing a move elsewhere or to the NFL in a more serious way than Ebel or others who are not walking. So it doesn’t mean a lot, but it’s a breadcrumb. 

2. Matt Campbell’s finish-strong mentality is a better fit for the 24-team CFP era

Penn State has clearly and tangibly improved throughout this season. Even when you factor in the competition level the Nittany Lions are facing, they’re inarguably playing better now than they were before the bye week. That’s largely intentional from a program with a developmental ethos. 

“I’m a big believer that, really from January when you get your team back and you start to build your team every year,” Campbell explained, “You’re building your team with the ability to be your best in November and December in mind.” 

In that past, you could argue that’s the wrong way to go about approaching your season. When you can only afford to lose one of two games, the end of the season isn’t “when it matters,” as Campbell said, because this year, losses to Wisconsin and Northwestern eliminated any hope of reaching the 12-team CFP.

Who cares if you were at your best in December for the Pop-Tarts Bowl if a September loss kept you out of the meaningful postseason? However, in the 24-team era, that philosophy might be the right approach.

There’s significantly more margin for error in a 24-team model. There will be plenty of four-loss teams that make the field, and simply reaching the CFP won’t be much of an accomplishment. It’ll be about what you do when you get there, so you can afford to spend the early part of the season building and troubleshooting to reach your final form. 

Even this year, without any signature wins on the resume and an 0-4 start to Big Ten play, Penn State would probably be on the fringes of the CFP conversation with an 8-4 finish. 

1. Why do “the right humans” have such a hard time focusing in the third quarter?

Once again, even in a 42-14 blowout win, Penn State was outscored in the third quarter by Minnesota. The 56-16 third-quarter margin this season has become a running storyline in these press conferences, and largely, from Campbell to Mouser’s answer on Tuesday, the explanation has been a lack of mental toughness on behalf of their players. 

“We’re not as mentally tough as we need to be, to be able to go out there and sustain success in the third quarter,” Mouser said Tuesday. 

The staff hasn’t abdicated a role in those failures, calling on themselves to give a better halftime message and coach more actively through those situations.

However, it’s notable that a staff led by a head coach in Campbell, who constantly preaches about having “the right humans” in the locker room, and explained again on Tuesday that that was his priority last December when he first landed the job, is openly questioning the mental toughness of those humans.

This presser may have been an all-time high for the number of times the word “leadership” was used. Yet, that doesn’t appear to be showing up in tangible ways on game day. The struggles won’t burn this team anymore, with Rutgers and Maryland up next, so the point is probably moot, but it’s just a difficult reality to reconcile.

Add us as a preferred source on Google