Skip to main content

Predicting which Penn State seniors walking for Senior Day will be back for a fifth year

The NCAA's new eligibility rules have opened the door for nine players walking on Senior Day to return, but it's hard to imagine they will all be back for 2027.
ByJosh Yourish
Penn State Nittany Lions linebacker Tony Rojas (13)
Penn State Nittany Lions linebacker Tony Rojas (13) | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

On Monday, Penn State released the list of 25 players who are walking for Senior Day when Penn State hosts Rutgers for its final game of the year in Week 12. On Tuesday, head coach Matt Campbell clarified that he doesn’t get into conversations with players regarding their future until after the season, so a player walking who still has eligibility remaining doesn’t necessarily mean they are gone after the year. 

There are nine such players walking on Saturday, as the NCAA’s new age-based eligibility rules granted fourth-year seniors from the 2023 high school class an additional season for 2027. It doesn’t mean nothing for a player to walk, however, because two such fourth-year seniors, Kooper Ebel and Benjamin Brahmer, are not walking and announced their return for 2027 on Tuesday. 

So, the group that is walking is at least mulling the idea of a departure, either for the NFL or the transfer portal. They could also just run it back in Happy Valley for another season. 

We’ll know their fate for certain in just a few weeks, but for now, it’s worth speculating and predicting where those players will end up this offseason and which ones Penn State should expect to be back. 

6-9. QB Jack Lambert, DE Bobby Mears, DE Aidan Probst, WR Ethan Black - transfer portal

Outside of Mears' 30 offensive snaps, primarily at fullback, this group has combined to play one offensive or defensive snap this season, as fourth-string quarterback Jack Lambert appeared in garbage time of Penn State’s Week 3 win over Buffalo. Black has played 20 snaps of special teams, primarily on kick coverage.

All of these players have collegiate eligibility remaining, so the most likely course of action is to transfer to a lower level and see if there is playing time for them there. However, it’s also possible that they leave eligibility on the table now that they have presumably graduated. 

5. Tony Rojas - NFL

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

Tony Rojas is probably the easiest prediction to make. Yes, he has a year left, but he’s likely to be a Day 2 pick in the NFL Draft. Only a year removed from a major knee injury, this is the perfect time to make the jump. His departure will open snaps for Alex Tatsch and Cam Smith at WILL linebacker. 

4. Anthony Donkoh - NFL

Donkoh is a three-year starter at both right guard and right tackle for Penn State; he’s far from a first-round prospect in this year’s draft, but he’s absolutely a player worthy of being selected. For the James Franklin holdovers like Donkoh, it’s fair to err a bit more on the side of them leaving rather than sticking around for another season as Campbell continues to make the program his own. 

That won’t be the case across the board, but I’d lean 60/40 Donkoh leaves. It's certainly more likely that he tests the NFL Draft waters, so it may just come down to what type of feedback he receives. 

3. Carson Hansen - return

Hansen has been excellent since Penn State schematically overhauled its run game during the bye week. A big, physical, battering ram of a runner, he may consider preserving his body and making the jump to the NFL without putting 150 more carries worth of tread on his tires next season. However, he’s not the type of explosive athlete who flies off the board early, so he’d probably make more money coming back to Penn State than he would as an NFL rookie, where there’s no guarantee he’d stick in the league. 

2. Andrew Rappleyea - return

After a major knee injury early in his Penn State career, Rappleyea has stacked two incredibly solid seasons in 2025 and 2026. But again, he’s not a top-flight prospect, and news of Brahmer’s return will absolutely not box him out of the offense, as offensive coordinator Taylor Mouser uses more 2- and 3-tight end sets than just about any other play-caller in the country. 

1. Zion Tracy - transfer portal

Far from a first-round pick, Zion Tracy is a man without a position at Penn State right now. A multi-year starter at nickel, he moved to safety out of necessity this season, but defensive coordinator D’Anton Lynn and Campbell have stated that outside corner might be his best position. 

Maybe the NFL is sold on his potential on the outside, but they’ve yet to see it. After a season of plugging holes on the back end for Penn State, Tracy could be ready to leave Happy Valley and find a team that will showcase his ability on the perimeter. Tracy has been very good and even more valuable to this defense, so a return would be welcome, but with the way this season has gone under another new defensive coordinator, this may be a natural breaking point.

Add us as a preferred source on Google