Much of the conversation this week in Happy Valley ahead of Penn State’s Senior Day matchup with Rutgers was about the future of Matt Campbell’s program. That future looks bit more bleak after his team went out and suffered the program’s first loss to Rutgers since 1988, easily one of the worst losses in program history.
Still, that didn’t stop four-star 2028 cornerback Damontae Butler from hopping on board. The Reynoldsburg, Ohio native committed to the Nittany Lions on Sunday, giving cornerbacks coach Terry Smith two huge wins in next year’s class. Penn State also holds a commitment from four-star in-state cornerback Deonte Flemings Jr., who is the No. 154 ranked player by 247Sports Composite.
Those same rankings peg Butler as the No. 348th-ranked player in the country and the No. 11 recruit in Ohio. Along with Smith’s ability to recruit defensive backs, Campbell has fared well in his home state since arriving in Happy Valley, but it appears as though his ace recruiter is setting him up for success.
Terry Smith has laid the foundation for Matt Campbell’s 2028 class
The 2027 Penn State class looks to be the distinct flavor of Campbell and his general manager, Derek Hoodjer. While it’s far and away the best class the former Iowa State duo has ever landed, much of that work was done by late-cycle ranking bumps, proving just how good this staff is at identifying underrecruited talent.
The 2028 class, however, seems to have Smith’s fingerprints all over it, at least early on. Of the four commits, two are cornerbacks, Smith’s position, and the other is a four-star quarterback from Smith’s hometown of Aliquippa, in Western Pennsylvania.
Smith clearly played a major role in James Armstrong's recruitment, the No. 10-ranked QB in the country, and he is credited as the primary recruiter for both Flemings and Butler. Those are three early-cycle, highly-ranked recruiting wins for the highest-paid non-coordinator assistant coach in college football, proving his worth.
Campbell and Hoodjer can find their hidden gems and cobble together a solid class that will rise late in the cycle, but that’s probably not a viable roster-building strategy year in and year out without the ability to win some big-time battles on the trail for highly-touted recruits. Smith is that guy for this staff and he’s laid the groundwork for what should be a really solid 2028 class, as long as Campbell and Hoodjer can hold up their end of the bargain.
Damontae Butler is Terry Smith’s type of corner
Still growing into a solid frame, Butler isn’t necessarily the long-rangy corner his 6-foot-1, 170-pound measurements hint at. He’s a bulldog on the outside, not afraid to stick his nose in the run game to make tackles, and he can send a message at the line of scrimmage in press coverage.
A good blitzer with a nose for the football, he might be best as a nickel at the next level, but he has inside-out versatility and has enough eye discipline to play zone coverage as well as man. He’s a good young football player who has an edge about him on tape, and that’s going to be a perfect fit in Smith’s cornerback room.

