Skip to main content

It’s hard not to ask what value Matt Campbell and Rocco Becht actually bring to Penn State

Matt Campbell and Rocco Becht are supposed to be the culture-setters in Happy Valley, and right now, the culture is second-half collapse.
ByJosh Yourish
Penn State Nittany Lions head coach Matt Campbell talks with quarterback Rocco Becht (3)
Penn State Nittany Lions head coach Matt Campbell talks with quarterback Rocco Becht (3) | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Matt Campbell is a culture-building head coach who has overachieved everywhere he’s gone. Not a play-caller on either side of the ball, he’s a CEO-type who has admitted that his priority in Year 1 at Penn State was to get the “right humans” and build the locker room before worrying about what the depth chart looks like. 

Rocco Becht is the most experienced quarterback in college football. An undersized four-year starter better known for his leadership and “veteranness,” as Campbell often praises, than his physical attributes, he immediately followed his head coach from Ames to Happy Valley. 

Yet, eight weeks after Penn State blew a 17-0 lead to Wisconsin at Beaver Stadium, the Nittany Lions blew a 16-0 lead to Rutgers in front of considerably fewer home fans, falling 25-24 for the program’s first loss to the Scarlet Knights in 38 years. All that culture and leadership hasn’t amounted to much, as the Nittany Lions are 6-5 after 12 weeks of the Campbell experience. 

Where is Matt Campbell's game-day value?

“It starts with coaching, and it starts with the head football coach,” Campbell said in his postgame press conference, as he attempted to explain the fourth-quarter meltdown. “I think it’s a trickle-down effect. Obviously, I didn’t have us prepared to play our best football game.” 

His quarterback didn’t exactly agree with Campbell shouldering so much responsibility. “I think we’re all pros, and whether you practiced a lot this week or whether you didn’t, I think we’re all old enough and mature enough to able to be locked in during practice and be detailed during practice, and be able to come out on Saturdays and execute our jobs. And then if you don’t, it maybe isn’t for you, and so I think he shouldn’t be able to take all that blame on himself.”

Campbell may not agree that his team is mature enough. In recent weeks, he’s explained the team’s continued third-quarter struggles as a lack of mental maturity and toughness. After this loss, he said, “It's a mentality to play 60 minutes to a standard. And that is not where we're at yet."

First, it’s hilarious to say “yet” 12 weeks into a 13-week season. Second, and more importantly, who is responsible for that? It’s not the head coach who isn’t spending his week game-planning to run either side of the ball, or the most experienced quarterback in college football? 

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

If that’s not what those two are specifically good for- steadying the football team when it wavers late in games and instilling mental toughness as a central tenet of the program- what exactly do they do? 

Penn State's leadership keeps failing in meltdown losses

Campbell certainly doesn’t manage the game well. Even if Greg Schiano didn’t bait him into burning a timeout by stealing a page from Lincoln Riley’s book, Campbell still managed to waste his timeouts before the final sequences of the fourth quarter. He’s continually been a negative in that aspect of his job, so it’s starting to be tough to pinpoint what exactly he does, at least on game day. 

Becht isn’t exactly a pinpoint passer. He went just 14/21 for 233 yards and a touchdown, leading a boom-or-bust passing game that was far from reliable, as the offense controlled the ball for less than 10 minutes in the entire second half with a fumble, three punts, and just one score. 

The run game was absent, with Carson Hansen and James Peoples out injured. Cam Wallace has proven to be a home run hitter, but struggled to hit singles and doubles as the lead back. Quinton Martin Jr. could hardly make contact, finishing with 12 yards on seven carries. 

Yet, Becht went 1-for-3 for 13 yards in the fourth quarter and wasn’t trusted to win the game through the air. So, if you don’t trust him to win the game with his arm and his leadership is amounting to consistent second-half collapses, it gets pretty difficult to see his value. Taylor Mouser pointed out his ability to manage the run game pre-snap this week, and that bears out statistically. Maybe there’s more hidden value, too, but after a loss to Rutgers, it’s hidden deeper than most Penn State fans will care to look. 

This team isn’t good. Maybe that’s the reality that Campbell’s talk of culture and mentality is meant to cover up. But even for the talent deficiencies, including at quarterback, which in some ways are out of Campbell’s control in this first year, the lack of leadership is evident in just about every second half this team has played. So it’s right that Penn State’s leaders should take much of the blame. 

In Campbell’s case, still in Year 1 of an eight-year contract, a leadership change is out of the question. At quarterback, with Becht out of eligibility, it’s inevitable. Hopefully, 1-for-2 with a massive talent upgrade everywhere else on the roster this offseason will be enough. Right now, it doesn’t feel like it.

Add us as a preferred source on Google