Richie Lucas is an interesting case for this list. The College Football Hall of Famer played three ways at Penn State, quarterback, defensive back, and punter, and finished second in Heisman voting in 1959, but his NFL career didn’t pan out, in large part because he chose the AFL.
Washington drafted Lucas, but instead, he signed with the Buffalo Bills of the AFL to become the franchise’s first player. So, Washington got no return on their first-round pick in 1960, and Buffalo only kept Lucas for two underwhelming seasons.
Lucas was acquired by Denver in 1962 through the equalization draft, but never played for the Broncos.