Penn State football was stunned on Saturday after Rutgers came into the Nittany Lions' senior day contest and pulled off a heroic win thanks to a last second lateral turned into a touchdown and successful two-point conversion that resulted in a 25-24 final score in Happy Valley.
Before the Scarlet Knights' touchdown, though, quarterback AJ Surace and Rutgers' offense was at the Penn State nine-yard line on fourth-and-eight with 10 seconds remaining on the clock. Surace sent the ball into the end zone, hoping to connect with wide receiver Ben Black III. The pass flew over the heads of both Black and cornerback Daryus Dixson and out the back of the end zone.
The incomplete pass should have resulted in a turnover on downs and a Nittany Lions victory, but the officials called a defensive pass interference on Dixson.
The defensive pass interference call that cost Penn State the game against Rutgers.
— Joel Haas (@Joel_Haas1) November 22, 2026
Some hand fighting and a jersey tug, but tough to make that call in that moment. Also, the ball might not have been catchable. pic.twitter.com/IvdOYZAplO
The officials initially called the penalty on cornerback Audavion Collins who was in coverage on the far end of the field, but Dixson was the defensive back on the play. There was some contact on the play, but certainly not enough to throw the flag, especially when the ball wasn't necessarily catchable for the Scarlet Knight receiver.
Controversial defensive pass interference penalty gives Rutgers another shot at upsetting Penn State
The penalty moved Rutgers up to the two-yard-line with six seconds left. They ultimately scored after Scarlet Knight running back Antwan Raymond gave the ball away to Black who finished off the play in the end zone.
The Nittany Lions had seven penalties on Saturday for 67 yards, and two of those were pass interferences calls: one on Dixson and the other on cornerback Audavion Collins on the same drive.
Rutgers with an unbelievable heads-up play to score a TD plus the 2 to pull off a stunner at Penn State. This play is nuts. pic.twitter.com/C6XTZDoB9f
— Mike Garafolo (@MikeGarafolo) November 22, 2026
One first-and-10 from Penn State's 41-yard-line, Collins broke up a pass intended for Black. The officials threw the flag, giving Rutgers a fresh set of downs at the Nittany Lions' 26-yard-line. Assistant head coach and cornerbacks coach Terry Smith was confused by this first call, pointing to the video board when the play replayed in Beaver Stadium.
While it was a bad call, Penn State technically had two opportunities to close out the game with a win on the next play and still couldn't deliver. The ensuing touchdown after the defensive pass interference penalty and the two-point conversion pass were both plays the Nittany Lions could've stopped.
Both sides of the ball for Penn State also allowed the Scarlet Knights to stay in the game unnecessarily. The Nittany Lions punted three times in the second half and fumbled a ball that Rutgers recovered. they had just one scoring drive in the back half of the game. The defense held Rutgers to four punts in the second half, but allowed two touchdowns in the fourth quarter, including the game-winner. In reality, that should've been four punts, one touchdown, and a game-sealing turnover on downs, though.

