More than short-handed, Penn State was practically playing with one hand tied behind its back in the embarrassing 25-24 Week 12 loss to Rutgers. Of course, no amount of injuries excuses the program’s first loss to Rutgers since 1988, and a quarterback, AJ Surace, playing with cracked ribs.
Still, the sheer quantity of significant injuries Penn State dealt with in Week 12 was staggering. Coming into the game, Penn State was without leading rusher Carson Hansen, on top of longer-standing injuries to Koby Howard, Jahmir Joseph, Caleb Bacon, and others. Then, in the first half, wide receiver Brett Eskildsen and running back James Peoples were lost for the game to injuries, and starting center Brock Riker was banged up, though he did return.
Underratedly, the position most impacted by late-season attrition, though, maybe even more than running back, was safety. Jamison Patton was a game-time decision and only played eight snaps, and, after being named as a starter in the stadium, Zion Tracy didn’t play a single snap.
Tracy’s absence was conspicuous, as Jeremiah Cooper played 71 of 75 snaps, Vaboue Toure stepped into a major role, and true freshman Bryson Williams even saw the field late in the game.
It was also unexplained until head coach Matt Campbell took the podium for his postgame press conference.
Zion Tracy “tweaked himself” in warmups
“The safety room took a hit,” Campbell said, “Zion tweaked himself really in pregame warmup. We thought he was going to be able to go, and he just wasn’t able to go.”
Tracy’s move from nickel to safety, which happened early in Big Ten play as Marcus Neal Jr. was phased out of the rotation, largely stabilized Penn State’s struggling defense. Without him on the field, the early-season issues, both communication in coverage and third-level tackling, reappeared as Rutgers erased a two-touchdown lead in the fourth quarter.
“We’ve got enough good football players to be able to play the way we needed to play, and we just didn’t today,” Campbell continued.
Penn State’s safety snap count vs. Rutgers
- Jeremiah Cooper: 71
- Vaboue Toure: 62
- Bryson Williams: 9
- Jamison Patton: 8
- Xxavier Thomas: 3 (slot)
- Marcus Neal Jr.: 1 (linebacker)
Even with Tracy’s absence, Penn State didn’t move Neal, who has been transitioning from safety to linebacker, back to safety. Instead, it was a heavy dose of Cooper, who has been on a pitch count at times this season after recovering from a major injury this offseason, and Toure, who had played 83 total snaps prior to Week 12.
Penn State should have been able to get off the field against Rutgers late with whoever was healthy enough to take the field, but the injuries at safety, running back, and everywhere else really exposed the lack of depth on this roster.
The focus of Penn State’s talent deficiencies this year has largely been on the lack of high-end talent, but for a staff that had to put together a portal class on short notice and nearly missed an entire recruiting cycle, it makes sense that depth would be a weakness as well.

