Skip to main content

Matt Campbell has dragged Penn State to a new low with 1st loss to Rutgers in 38 years

There are plenty of excuses for Penn State's 25-24 Week 12 loss to Rutgers, but none of them are good enough.
ByJosh Yourish
Penn State Nittany Lions head coach Matt Campbell
Penn State Nittany Lions head coach Matt Campbell | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

All week in Happy Valley, the talk was about the future of the program. First-year head coach Matt Campbell and his staff had seemingly resuscitated the season during their Week 8 bye, leading to three straight wins after starting Big Ten play 0-4. 

It seemed to be a foregone conclusion that after the wretched 3-4 start, Campbell would lead his team to an 8-4 finish with Rutgers and Maryland as the final two opponents of the season. Then, Campbell did the unthinkable, losing to the Scarlet Knights 25-24 on a walk-off two-point conversion after a desperate lateral from Rutgers running back Antwan Raymond to Ben Black III on the final timed down of the game. 

There have been some good Rutgers teams in the 38 years since the program last defeated the Nittany Lions in 1988. To be clear, this is not one of them. This team lost to UMass in the first week of the season and came into Week 12 ranked No. 114 in SP+, one spot behind Central Michigan. Penn State was No. 42 and favored by 24.5 points at home, only to allow 15 unanswered points and blow a two-touchdown lead in the fourth quarter. 

There are plenty of excuses for why this team isn’t up to Penn State’s standard, and even a few reasonable excuses for why this game slipped away, including a horrible pass interference call on Daryus Dixson on fourth-and-9 with 10 seconds left that would have ended the game a play before Raymond’s lateral to Black. 

But when it’s Rutgers, none of those excuses cut it

Injuries aren’t an excuse to lose to Rutgers

Penn State came into the game without its leading rusher, Carson Hansen. Added to Koby Howard’s near season-long absence, the Nittany Lions are without their two most effective offensive weapons. Then, in the first quarter, wide receiver Brett Eskildsen and running back James Peoples went down, leaving Penn State to rely heavily on Zay Robinson and Quinton Martin Jr. in outsized roles. 

Even center Brock Riker had to be helped to the sideline at the end of the first half before returning to play after the intermission, presumably at less than 100%. Those are all significant injuries for an offense that has relied heavily on big plays in the passing game and newfound success on the ground since the bye week. 

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

Without Hansen, Penn State’s run game managed a 41% success rate and just 150 total yards, 56 of which came on a Wallace touchdown run in the first quarter. Wallace is clearly a big-play threat, but wasn’t reliable down-to-down, didn’t get tough yards in short-yardage situations as Penn State went 0-2 on fourth down, and Martin was woefully ineffective, rushing for 12 yards on seven carries. 

The passing game was boom or bust, and turnovers were costly. Defensively, D’Anton Lynn’s passive game plans and this team’s lack of a dynamic pass rush have left it susceptible to second-half comebacks all season. Even zooming out, there are explanations for those issues. 

Pat Kraft put Matt Campbell behind the eight-ball, but not this far behind

The fact that Pat Kraft took so long to hire Campbell and whiffed on his other pursuits as the early signing period passed and the transfer portal window arrived obviously handcuffed this regime in their first offseason. Campbell has pretty much said as much, admitting he was focused more on building a locker room than a cohesive roster because he had so little time. 

That scramble and a near-missed recruiting class have left Penn State shockingly devoid of talent. That is just as real an excuse as the injuries this week and the consistently terrible Big Ten refs. But that still doesn’t add up to a loss to Rutgers inside Beaver Stadium. It just can’t. 

Campbell has proven himself to be inept at managing close games, wasting timeouts in less-than-ideal spots and allowing or enabling both of his play-callers to go into a shell, playing not to lose. Was Hansen’s absence or conservative play-calling more to blame for the lack of sustained drives in the second half? Probably the latter, because since the bye week, the former made conservative play-calling look like the right decision. But it can’t take that long to adjust. You can’t leave the door open. And from his very first Big Ten game at Penn State, Campbell always seems to. 

The best part is that Campbell has spent much of the recent weeks describing the team’s second-half struggles as a lack of mental toughness and maturity. Maybe that’s true, but isn’t culture-building supposed to be his entire thing? Isn’t one of the reasons this team doesn’t have more talent because he prioritized that culture above everything else this offseason? 

Matt Campbell is all about “growing forward,” but this game looked a lot like Week 4, when he watched helplessly as Wisconsin stole a game at Beaver Stadium. 

This is a new low for Penn State, somehow even lower than the depth of last season when James Franklin was fired. And with the eight-year contract Kraft had to put on the table to lure Campbell away from Ames, he can’t just blow it all up again. But maybe the administration can, starting with the AD who made this mess.

Add us as a preferred source on Google