September 15, 2012; Stanford, CA, USA; Southern California Trojans running back Silas Redd (25) is helped off the field by medical staff members after an injury during the second quarter against the Stanford Cardinal at Stanford Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kyle Terada-US PRESSWIRE

Defected Penn Staters May Deter Future Players From Doing the Same

Regardless of what some of the Penn State internet writers would have you believe, not every Penn State performance is a tryout for “free agency” in the offseason. In fact, shows like the one that Allen Robinson is putting on this season may reinforce players decisions to remain at Penn State. Luckily for the current team, the players who left in July/August are proving to the current roster that the grass isn’t always greener.

First, Khairi Fortt (Cal) and Anthony Fera (Texas) are hurt, so we’ll take them out of the conversation.

Tight end Kevin Haplea left Penn State for Florida State, where he has one reception for three yards through three games. Meanwhile, five Penn State tight ends have at least one catch, including converted quarterback Paul Jones. Three of them have touchdowns. If you’re a tight end at Penn State, you’re going to see the field, you’re going to get targets and you’re going to get touchdowns. Still, Haplea does get to live in Florida and he does play on a good team.

Quarterback Rob Bolden left spring practice as the third string QB and transferred to LSU. He is listed as the third string QB on LSU’s roster, however, three different signal callers have thrown passes for the Tigers, and none of them are named Rob Bolden. He may be looking at a redshirt season. At Penn State, Matt McGloin is playing the best ball of his career and true freshman Steven Bench has moved up the depth chart and saw action against Virginia. O’Brien has shown that he will put the best players on the field regardless of everything else.

Justin Brown left for Oklahoma, where it was expected that playing in an offense with Landry Jones would bolster his draft stock and give him a shot at a championship. Through two games, Brown has six catches for 87 yards. Allen Robinson has had that many yards in each of the first three games. Would it be wise for a receiver to leave an offense where he is targeted double-digit times per game?

Silas Redd left for the chance to play for a national championship at USC. In their loss to Stanford last week, Redd had 13 carries for 17 yards. His dream of a national championship is still alive, but it will be an uphill climb. More people know Silas’ name now than they did three months ago, but that only goes so far.

Ryan Nowicki has not yet played in Illinois.

Tim Buckley hasn’t seen the field at North Carolina State.

Of course, these decisions are made based on more than just football. It’s small-minded of me or anyone else *COUGH*Ron Musselman*COUGH* to pretend otherwise. Ryan Nowicki had friends in the Chicago area. Tim Buckley, who would likely have seen significant snaps at Penn State by now, is from North Carolina.  Redd, Brown, Bolden and Haplea all have shots (some more distant than others) at winning a national championship. They’ll likely all play, or at least travel to a bowl this season, as well.

On the other end of it, Silas Redd has been vocal about the negative aspect of his parents not being able to be his games. A transfer means leaving your teammates, friends and home. It means getting acclimated to new surroundings and a new campus, all while learning a new playbook and forming new relationships. It’s so much more than the “I’m good, they’re good, this will be easy” mentality that many people view it as.

Will guys like Allen Robinson and Deion Barnes be recruited this offseason? You better believe it. However, they should take a second to remember why it is that these schools are calling and who helped put them in that position. When you’re “the man” at one place, leaving to be “just another guy” at another may not be the best route. For the present or the future.

For all of the latest on the Penn State Nittany Lions, follow VBR Lead Editor Tim Tolley on Twitter.


Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: Football Oklahoma Sooners Penn State Nittany Lions Usc Trojans

  • pittsnogle26

    I would have waited to write this article to see how the rest of the season went. If PSU finishes with a 4-8 record or worse, the players are going to transfer. Bolden may not be playing but he is getting a shot at a National Title. Haplea also has a shot a National Championship or at least a ACC Championship and Orange Bowl bid. Bottom line being that the majority of these players have a chance to play in a bowl or National Championship. No brainer to leave if your loyalty isn’t to the school.

    • Tim Tolley

      I think that’s a small-minded approach to the situation. If winning national championships was the only thing that mattered, nobody would ever commit to schools like Pitt and Rutgers. Also, 50 kids would have transferred in August, compared to the 8 or 9 that did. Kids are loyal to each other, their school, friends, coaches, etc. It would have taken a LOT for me to just pick up and leave my friends when I was 20.
      Also, only ONE of the kids who left has a chance of winning a national championship. The rest can only hope for second. Some who left and will leave will have hurt their draft stock doing so. That’s another reason to stay, depending on the situation.

  • greg

    Let’s stay level headed here. If this team finishes with a losing record, the players are going to transfer. Conference championship and national championship opportunities are very hard to pass up. Same thing goes for some of the current recruits. In short, enjoy this season and hope for the best.

  • Chilli

    Don’t forget what these kids were/will be promised by other programs. Kids like A Rob are now proven commodities and will be pursued, AGGRESSIVELY, by opposing coaching staffs over recruits out of high school.